#68: Protestant YouTube Star Becomes Catholic—Lizzie Estella Reezay

#68: Protestant YouTube Star Becomes Catholic—Lizzie Estella Reezay

She didn’t want to do it.

No way, no how.

Not becoming Catholic.

Lizzie was an established and very popular presence in the “young Protestant dispenses advice to the like-minded” space on YouTube; she grew up in the Church of Christ and imbibed the standard myths about Catholicism. She might pray for Catholics, but become one? Riiiiiight.

Attending Pepperdine University in Malibu, CA, Lizzie began to run into fellow Protestants who were either intensely interested in the Faith or had converted to full membership. Meanwhile, her YouTube channel began to really grow wings. (As of this writing, she has 34,808,077 total views.)

Perhaps wanting to be kind and informative, Lizzie ended up shooting some video commentaries with titles like “Seven Lies Protestants Believe About Catholicism,” and “Questions Protestants Have For Catholics.”

Then she discovered the Church fathers, and, in her revelatory video called (wait for it) “Why I Am Becoming Catholic,” she goes one to explain how the book Upon This Rock by Steve Ray was instrumental in her decision. I grinned audibly. My buddy Steve!

My interview with her, as you’ll see, was a delight. She is direct, candid, and very open about her diagnosis with bipolar disorder. Her journey is about to take a profound leap forward when she enters full communion with the Catholic Church at Easter, 2018.

Pray for this young leader. As an evangelist and content creator for Christ, Lizzie Estella Reezay is going places.


In this interview, you will learn:

  • How her experience of being immersed in misconceptions of Catholicism led to acceptance of countless errors of fact
  • Why you can’t be too careful which authors you read…
  • The one book that supercharged Lizzie’s desire to get to the bottom of The Catholic Thing
  • How her friends and family reacted to the news of her conversion
  • Tools in how to, and how not to, reach out to our separated brethren

Resources mentioned in this episode:


The Patrick Coffin Show is 100% listener supported. Help us keep our show independent and unfiltered.
Consider supporting our work with a one-time or recurring donation HERE.


Tweet to Patrick HERE

Follow Patrick on Facebook HERE

Check out the store HERE

Sign up for our Inside Scoop newsletter with the best of The Patrick Coffin Show each week.


Join the Conversation

Question of the week:

  • Why is the best part of apologetics getting out of your own way and listening?


Comment below.


Don’t forget to Subscribe to the show in YouTube, as well as the podcast so you can get the weekly show updates. Check the podcast in iTunes and other podcast directories, while you are there, please leave an honest review.

Ratings and reviews are extremely helpful and greatly appreciated!




If you enjoyed this episode, please share it using the social media buttons below.

Connect with me on social media:

Tweet to Patrick HERE

Follow Patrick on Facebook HERE

Subscribe to the Podcast

(Click on the images and then click on susbcribe)

While you are there, please leave an honest review.

Ratings and reviews are extremely helpful and greatly appreciated!

Related Posts

If you want to build a better culture, climb aboard.